The plaintiff group includes the owner of two churches and a Calgary gym. They called for the immediate cessation of public health orders relating to COVID-19, such as restrictions on meetings and the wearing of mandatory masks, until an appeal is heard in court.
The judge said she did not believe the risk posed by COVID-19 was real and that it was in the public interest to suspend sanctions without having to wait until they could continue their course.
On December 8, Alberta imposed a series of sanctions in an attempt to smooth out the number of cases, including the closure of restaurants, bars and casinos.
The judge ruled that Health Chief Medical Officer Dinah Hinsha had the authority to take action to protect public health.
Applicants are questioning the need for sanctions to be imposed on the general population in Alberta. This part of the argument goes a long way, Said Judge Kirker.
Heights in Medicine hat include Baptist churches and the Northside plaintiff in Calgary. They argue that their constitutional rights are being violated by restrictions, including the restriction of meetings of a social or religious nature.
Roth & Company and the Legal Center for Constitutional Freedom argue that Albertans under the age of 60 are more likely to be killed and that sanctions cause more than death from COVID-19
Much more harm than good caused by COVID-19 . The government also argued that
Bankrupt businesses and the Alberts deny all their rights under the Alberta Rights Bill and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms..
Nick Parker, a lawyer representing the Alberta government, argued that it did not have the clear limit needed to obtain an order.
The source of their argument is that the authoritarian Dr. Deena Hinsha will weaken democracy by passing laws, He announced.
In fact, I would say that what we are seeing is not outrageous or illegal legislation. One of the biggest public health crises this province has seen is what we see in the action of democracy, Added.
Even if the injunction request is denied, the case can be heard later if the plaintiff decides to proceed.
860 people have lost their lives in Alberta since the outbreak began.